5 Types of Magento 2 Elasticsearch Reindex Explained

• What is Magento 2 Elasticsearch Reindex?

• Why is Elasticsearch Reindex Necessary for Magento 2 Search Functionality?

• Comparing the 5 Types of Magento 2 Elasticsearch Reindex Processes

• Step-by-Step Guide to Performing Magento 2 Elasticsearch Reindex

• Troubleshooting Common Elasticsearch Reindexing Issues

• Alternative Procedures to Magento 2 Elasticsearch Reindex

• FAQs

• Summary

What is Magento 2 Elasticsearch Reindex?

“Magento 2 Elasticsearch reindex updates the index for your store. It reflects changes in your Magento 2 database. This keeps your search engine accurate for products and data.”

Magento 2 uses Elasticsearch for searching. Elasticsearch requires its own index of your data. This index helps deliver fast search results. The index requires a manual update to reflect changes in Magento.

Reindexing synchronizes Elasticsearch with your database. Without reindexing, customers may miss new products or see old information. They could also receive inaccurate search results.

Elasticsearch reindexing is essential for a functional Magento 2 store. It affects the quality of your site's search experience.

Why is Elasticsearch Reindex Necessary for Magento 2 Search Functionality?

1. Accurate and Up-to-Date Search Results

• Reflects Product Catalog Changes: Reindexing incorporates new products and updated information into search. Customers see current product offerings when they search your store.

• Updates Category/Attribute Data: Category structures and product attributes need reindexing for filters. Search navigation breaks without proper updates to these critical elements.

• Applies Configuration Changes: Admin search settings need reindexing to take effect. Search relevance depends on the proper application of your configurations.

• Keeps Pace with Dynamic Data: Stores with frequent updates need consistent reindexing cycles. Real-time data accuracy demands regular index synchronization for success.

• Prevents Data Staleness: Without reindexing, search results become outdated and misleading. Customers abandon stores that show unavailable or mispriced items.

2. Search Performance and Speed

• Maintains Index Efficiency: Reindexing prevents fragmentation and maintains optimal index structure. Performance degrades when indexes accumulate changes without proper maintenance.

• Reduces Search Latency: Up-to-date indexes deliver search results with minimal delay. Customers leave websites that make them wait for search results.

• Enables Advanced Search Features: Faceted search and synonym support need proper indexing. These features fail without the foundation of synchronized Elasticsearch data.

• Handles Large Catalogs: Growing product catalogs need reindexing for scalable search. Large stores collapse under their weight without index management.

• Prevents Search Engine Overload: Incremental reindexing distributes the processing load over time. This approach prevents server crashes during peak shopping periods.

3. Flexibility and Control

• Full Reindex for Major Changes: Schema changes demand complete index rebuilds for consistency. No other method guarantees proper synchronization after fundamental modifications.

• Partial Reindex for Incremental Updates: Daily changes need efficient update methods for speed. Full reindexing for minor changes squanders server resources.

• "Update by Save" for Real-Time Indexing: Shoppers want immediate updates to search results. This indexing mode meets customer expectations for fresh data.

• Scheduled Reindexing for Controlled Updates: Resource management benefits from planned indexing during off-hours. This approach balances system load with search accuracy needs.

• Manual Reindexing for On-Demand Control: Troubleshooting search issues requires direct indexing control. Developers need this tool to resolve search problems with efficiency.

4. Testing and Development Reliability

• Sandbox Environment Synchronization: Test environments need reindexing for valid search testing. Skipping this step renders all search functionality tests meaningless.

• Validates Data Imports and Migrations: New data needs verification through the search index. Reindexing confirms the correct appearance of imported products in search results.

• Troubleshooting Search Issues: Diagnostics start with reindexing to cut basic problems. This step rules out synchronization issues before a deeper investigation begins.

• Supports Extension Development: Search-related extensions must integrate with the indexing process. Developers need an understanding of reindexing for successful extensions.

• Ensures Consistent Environments: Development and production environments must maintain search parity. Reindexing creates consistency across all deployment stages.

5. Positive Customer Experience

• Improved Product Discoverability: Customers find products faster with accurate search indexes. Sales increase when shoppers locate what they want.

• Reduced Customer Frustration: Outdated search results drive customers to competitor sites. Reindexing prevents the disappointment of finding unavailable products.

• Increased Customer Satisfaction: Reliable search builds trust in your store brand. Shoppers return to stores where the search works as expected.

• Supports Mobile Search: Mobile users demand fast, accurate search for small screens. Efficient indexes deliver the speed mobile commerce requires.

• Competitive Advantage: Stores with superior search outperform their market rivals. Reindexing forms the foundation of this critical competitive edge.

Comparing the 5 Types of Magento 2 Elasticsearch Reindex Processes

1. Scope of Index Update

Feature	Full Reindex	Partial Reindex	Update by Save	Scheduled Reindexing	Manual Reindexing
Scope	Entire Index	Changed Data	Individual Entity (on save)	Varies (Full or Partial)	Varies (Full or Partial)
Data Processed	All Data	Only Modified Data	Specific Entity	Depends on Schedule	Depends on Command
Index Rebuilt	Yes, to the fullest extent.	No, updates existing	No, updates existing	Depends on Schedule	Depends on Command
Synchronization	Complete, from scratch	Incremental	Near Real-time	Scheduled Interval	On-Demand

2. Performance and Resource Usage

Feature	Full Reindex	Partial Reindex	Update by Save	Scheduled Reindexing	Manual Reindexing
Resource Usage	High	Low to Medium	Low (per save)	Depends on Scope	Depends on Scope
Execution Time	Longest	Shorter	Fastest (per save)	Depends on Scope	Depends on Scope
Performance Impact	Highest (temporary)	Minimal	Minimal (per save, potential cumulative impact)	Depends on Scope & Schedule	Depends on Scope
Efficiency	Least Efficient	More Efficient	Most Efficient for incremental changes	Can be efficient if partial/scheduled well	Flexible efficiency

3. Automation and Trigger

Feature	Full Reindex	Partial Reindex	Update by Save	Scheduled Reindexing	Manual Reindexing
Automation Level	None (Manual Command)	Semi-Automatic (Update by Save)	Automatic	Automated (Cron Job)	None (Manual Command)
Trigger Mechanism	Manual CLI Command	Magento Events (Data Save) or CLI	Magento Events (Data Save)	Cron Job Schedule	Manual CLI Command
Real-time Updates	No	Yes (via Update by Save)	Yes (Near Real-time)	No (Scheduled Delay)	No (On-Demand)
Best for Real-time	No	Yes (Partial, via Update by Save)	Yes (Update by Save)	No	No

4. Use Cases and Frequency

Feature	Full Reindex	Partial Reindex	Update by Save	Scheduled Reindexing	Manual Reindexing
When to Use	Major changes, schema updates, troubleshooting	Regular updates, daily changes	Real-time updates, immediate synchronization	Batch updates, off-peak indexing, less critical data	On-demand updates, troubleshooting, deployments
Frequency	Infrequent, as needed	Frequent, ongoing	Continuous, on each save	Periodic, as scheduled	As needed, on-demand
Ideal for	Large-scale changes, index rebuild	Incremental changes, keeping the index current	Up-to-the-minute search accuracy	Controlled timing, resource management	Direct control, specific scenarios
Example Triggers	Magento upgrade, large data import, Elasticsearch version change	Product price update, new product addition, category modification	Saving a product in Magento Admin, API product update	Nightly updates, weekly price sync	Post-deployment index sync, immediate update after configuration change

5. Control and Flexibility

Feature	Full Reindex	Partial Reindex	Update by Save	Scheduled Reindexing	Manual Reindexing
User Control	Highest (Full Control)	Medium (Automatic trigger, manual command available)	Lowest (System-driven)	Medium (Schedule configuration)	Highest (Full Control)
Flexibility	Least Flexible (All or Nothing)	Semi-flexible (Automatic for most changes, manual override)	Least Flexible (Always on for configured indexers)	Semi-flexible (Schedule adjustments)	Most Flexible (Start any time)
Customization	Limited (Standard Rebuild)	Limited (Standard Incremental Update)	Configuration-based (Indexer Mode)	Schedule Configuration	Command Options
Troubleshooting Tool	Yes (Force Rebuild)	Yes (Verify Incremental Updates)	Limited (Track Performance)	Limited (Schedule Adjustments)	Yes (Direct Intervention)

Step-by-Step Guide to Performing Magento 2 Elasticsearch Reindex

Step 1: Access Magento 2 Server via SSH

• Open your terminal or SSH client. Connect to your server.

• Use SSH credentials (username and password or SSH key).

• Navigate to the Magento 2 root directory using cd.

Step 2: Check Indexer Status (Optional but Recommended)

• Run the following command to check the indexer status:

  php bin/magento indexer:status

• The command lists all indexers and their statuses.

• Find the catalogsearch_fulltext indexer (or relevant indexers).

Step 3: Perform Full Reindex (If Needed)

• To reindex all indexers, use this command:

  php bin/magento indexer:reindex

• To reindex the catalogsearch_fulltext indexer, use:

  php bin/magento indexer:reindex catalogsearch\_fulltext

• Wait for reindexing to complete. They will show progress.

Step 4: Perform Partial Reindex (Usually Automatic or Triggered by Changes)

• Partial reindexing occurs without manual intervention in "Update by Save" mode.

• Trigger a partial reindex if you invalidate the indexers.

  php bin/magento indexer:reindex catalogsearch\_fulltext

• Running php bin/magento indexer:reindex reindexes all "Require Reindex" indexers.

Step 5: Verify Reindex Completion and Search Results

• Run the following command to check the indexer status:

  php bin/magento indexer:status

• Test search functionality on your store's frontend.

• Clear Magento cache using php bin/magento cache:clean.

Step 6: Setting Indexer Mode to "Update by Save" (Recommended for Elasticsearch)

• Set catalogsearch_fulltext to "Update by Save" mode:

  php bin/magento indexer:set-mode realtime catalogsearch\_fulltext

• To set all indexers to "Update by Save":

  php bin/magento indexer:set-mode realtime

• Verify the indexer mode using:

  php bin/magento indexer:show-mode

• Confirm catalogsearch_fulltext is in "Real-time" mode.

Troubleshooting Common Elasticsearch Reindexing Issues

1. Connection Errors

• Verify that the Elasticsearch server runs on your system.

• Check that the Magento configuration matches the server settings.

• Review logs for specific connection error messages.

2. Indexing Errors

• Examine Magento logs for detailed error messages.

• Look in system.log and exception.log for clues.

• Research specific Elasticsearch error codes online.

3. Indexer Locks

• Run php bin/magento indexer:status to check locks.

• Clear locks with database tools with caution.

• Restart the PHP-FPM service when the locks persist.

4. Performance Issues

• Track server resources during reindex operations.

• Optimize Elasticsearch settings for better performance.

• Schedule reindexing during low-traffic hours.

5. Command Errors

• Verify command syntax with php bin/magento help indexer:reindex.

• Check indexer names using php bin/magento indexer:info.

• Confirm proper file permissions for bin/magento.

Alternative Procedures to Magento 2 Elasticsearch Reindex

1. Direct Elasticsearch API Manipulation (Advanced and Risky)

• Procedure: Custom scripts interact firsthand with the Elasticsearch REST API to index data. They bypass Magento's indexers.

• When to consider this (with extreme caution):

  • Specialized indexing requirements.

  • Data migration scenarios.

  • Deep troubleshooting.

• Major Caveats and Risks:

  • Bypasses Magento's data integrity.

  • It can lead to a maintenance nightmare.

  • Loss of Magento features and security risks (not recommended for general use)

2. Queue-Based Indexing (Asynchronous Processing)

• Procedure: Use a message queue (RabbitMQ, Redis Queue) to decouple indexing. Magento publishes messages on data changes, workers processes the queue and updates Elasticsearch.

• When to consider this:

  • High-volume "Update by Save" overload

  • Improved resilience.

• Caveats and Considerations:

  • More complexity

  • Possible delay in indexing.

  • Magento message queue setup

  • Still best with the Magento framework.

3. "Index on Demand" or Batch Indexing (Manual Trigger)

• Procedure: Disable "Update by Save." Reindex only when user-initiated, such as after data imports or deployments.

• When to consider this:

  • Very large catalogs with infrequent updates.

  • Specific maintenance windows.

• Caveats and Considerations:

  • Search data staleness.

  • Need for clear processes.

  • Fewer real-time experiences.

4. Third-Party Search Solutions (Alternative to Elasticsearch)

• Procedure: Replace Magento's Elasticsearch with a third-party cloud search service (Algolia, Searchanise, Klevu).

• When to consider this:

  • Dissatisfaction with Elasticsearch

  • Managed search service

  • Specific feature requirements.

• Caveats and Considerations:

  • Vendor lock-in, cost.

  • Integration complexity.

  • Data privacy and security.

Note: It's best to use Magento's built-in Elasticsearch indexing framework. Alternatives are complex, risky, and usually unnecessary for standard Magento stores.

FAQs

1. How often should I perform a full reindex in Magento 2 Elasticsearch?

Reindexing should happen rarely. It's needed after big changes. It includes Magento upgrades, large data imports, Elasticsearch updates, or fixing index issues. Partly reindexing or "Update by Save" is enough for regular day-to-day operations. Avoid unnecessary full reindexes as they are resource-intensive.

2. Will reindexing slow down my Magento 2 store?

Full reindexing can affect store performance, especially during peak traffic. It is resource-intensive. Partial reindexing and "Update by Save" have less impact. Schedule full reindexes during off-peak hours.

3. What happens if I don't reindex Magento 2 Elasticsearch?

Without reindexing, your Elasticsearch index falls out of sync. It causes inaccurate search results. Customers won’t find new products. Outdated information persists. Reindex at regular intervals for accurate search results and to avoid lost sales.

4. How can I determine if reindexing is necessary in Magento 2?

Use the command php bin/magento indexer:status. Update the indexers that have the status "Require Reindex." Magento invalidates indexers when relevant data changes occur, indicating the need for reindexing.

5. Is "Update by Save" mode always the best option for Elasticsearch reindexing?

For the catalogsearch_fulltext indexer, use "Update by Save". It fits best for real-time updates. In high-volume scenarios, check performance. "Update by Schedule" is for less critical indexers or to manage server load.

6. Can I automate Magento 2 Elasticsearch reindexing?

You can automate reindexing in different ways. "Update by Save" mode allows near real-time indexing. You can schedule reindexing with cron jobs. Programmatic reindexing uses Magento's indexer APIs to trigger updates.

Summary

Pick the Magento 2 Elasticsearch Reindex type based on how often you update data. For optimal search performance, use Elasticsearch. The catalogsearch_fulltext indexer recommends "Update by Save." Consider the below tutorial highlights for efficient index management:

• Track the indexer status to identify when you need to reindex. Keeping indexes up-to-date provides accurate search results.

• Focus on "Update by Save" for real-time search synchronization. This mode provides the best customer experience.

• Use full reindexing in a measured way and only when necessary. Overuse can strain server resources.

• Troubleshoot common reindexing errors without delay. Addressing issues maintains search functionality and store performance.

• Test search functionality after every reindex operation. Verification confirms that reindexing was successful and search results are accurate.

Managed Magento Hosting provides expert support for Elasticsearch reindexing and troubleshooting.